Steady Through the Uncertainty: Serving Clients in a Challenging Market
Why Homeowners Stay Put and How REALTORS Can Help (3 of 4)

“We’d like something smaller. We just don’t know where we would go.”
Sound familiar? No doubt our members have heard that more than once as they serve clients throughout Eastern Middle Tennessee.
For a longtime homeowner, selling can look attractive until the conversation turns to the next purchase. A smaller house may come with a larger monthly payment. A different location may mean leaving neighbors, familiar routines, or family nearby.
Those concerns deserve more attention than a reminder that the owner has substantial equity.
Understand the reasons behind the decision
A Redfin analysis published in March found that the typical U.S. homeowner had owned their current home for 12 years as of 2025. The report identified financial incentives to stay put, including low existing mortgage payments or having no mortgage, as factors affecting older homeowners.
That national pattern helps explain one constraint on housing turnover. When owners delay selling, fewer of their homes become available to other households. But an individual homeowner’s decision involves more than the market’s need for listings.
Some owners are happy where they are. Others want to move but see no affordable alternative. Still others are considering a change because stairs, upkeep, or distance from family have become difficult.
Ask what’s working about the current home and what has become harder. Avoid assuming that age alone tells you someone’s plans. A helpful conversation gives the owner room to describe the life they want, including the possibility of staying.
Compare complete options
When an owner is considering a move, develop a realistic estimate of sale proceeds after transaction costs and any mortgage payoff. Then help them investigate the cost and availability of homes that meet their needs.
That comparison should account for more than purchase price. Encourage clients to review likely taxes, insurance, association fees, and maintenance, along with moving expenses. Their lender can address financing questions, and tax or legal questions belong with the appropriate advisers.
Practical details also matter. How would the owner coordinate selling and buying? What would happen if the two transactions didn’t line up? Would a proposed replacement home actually reduce the maintenance or accessibility concerns that prompted the conversation?
Use current local information rather than assuming a national inventory headline describes the homes this owner would consider. The question is whether a workable next step exists for this person.
Be useful before a listing agreement
An owner who stays may still appreciate a resource for evaluating accessibility improvements or planning future maintenance. Ask whether they would like occasional information about suitable properties, and respect their answer.
Our REALTORS across Wilson, Smith, DeKalb, and Trousdale counties can also bring these experiences into broader community conversations about housing choices, helping explain the need for options that serve households at different stages of life.
As we approach Thanksgiving, it’s worth remembering what we’re asking someone to consider leaving. A home may hold decades of ordinary days and important milestones. Being grateful for a client’s trust means taking those attachments seriously while helping them evaluate the practical choices ahead.
Click here for a menu of EMTAR Consumer Resources.
About EMTAR: Chartered in 1969, our Association’s 1,200+ REALTORS are a proud part of the 36,000+ members of Tennessee REALTORS and of the 1.5 million+ members of NAR, all working to serve the public and protect the rights of America’s property owners. EMTAR members are known not only for their unmatched real estate excellence and high ethical standards, but also for being generous, hospitable, others-focused, loyal, hardworking, and eager to help wherever and whenever help is needed.